Short Answer — GameStop will purchase broken consoles, controllers, and games for cash or store credit, with some restrictions. For defective items, GameStop will typically deduct a refurbishing fee of up to about $60 from your trade-in offer.

Yes, GameStop does buy broken controllers, as well as other gaming consoles, accessories, and games. They offer both cash or store credit for these items. However, it’s important to note that GameStop may charge a refurbishment fee, which is usually around sixty dollars, for accepting broken controllers.